The Vineyard movement occupies a distinctive place in modern Christian history. Emerging from the Jesus Movement of the 1970s, it brought together elements that had often existed separately within Christianity: evangelical commitment to Scripture and evangelism, charismatic expectations concerning the Holy Spirit, contemporary worship music, church planting, and a strong emphasis on the present reality of the Kingdom of God.
At the center of the movement was John Wimber, a former rock musician who became an influential evangelical pastor, teacher, church planter, and advocate for healing and the charismatic gifts. Under his leadership, a handful of churches became an international movement.
The Vineyard also became closely associated with some of the most significant developments in contemporary Christian worship. Songs originating in Vineyard churches helped move evangelical worship away from hymns and choruses toward the intimate, congregational worship style that has become commonplace in churches around the world.
Its history, however, has not been without controversy. The Toronto Blessing of the 1990s became one of the most famous—and controversial—episodes in charismatic Christianity. The Vineyard’s eventual separation from the Toronto church demonstrated the tension within Wimber’s vision between openness to the Holy Spirit and the desire to remain firmly rooted in evangelical theology.
More recently, the departure of Vineyard Anaheim, the movement’s mother church, from Vineyard USA in 2022 provided another significant and painful chapter in the movement’s history.
The Background: Pentecostalism, the Charismatic Movement, and the Jesus Movement
To understand the Vineyard, it is helpful to understand the movements that preceded it.
The Pentecostal movement emerged in the early twentieth century, particularly through revivals such as the Azusa Street Revival beginning in Los Angeles in 1906. Pentecostals emphasized the continuing work of the Holy Spirit, including spiritual gifts such as speaking in tongues, prophecy, and healing.
The Charismatic Movement emerged within established Protestant and Catholic churches beginning particularly in the 1960s. Charismatics shared many Pentecostal beliefs about the Holy Spirit while remaining within traditional denominations.
Then came the Jesus Movement of the late 1960s and 1970s.
Young people associated with the counterculture began converting to Christianity. They brought with them different styles of dress, music, evangelism, and worship.
Some established churches struggled to accommodate them.
But other ministries embraced them.
The Vineyard ultimately emerged from this environment. Vineyard Canada describes the movement as part of what later became known as the “Third Wave” of charismatic Christianity: a movement that sought the experience and ministry of the Holy Spirit without necessarily embracing all the structures or distinctives of classical Pentecostalism.
Kenn Gulliksen and the Birth of the Vineyard
The movement’s first important leader was not John Wimber but Kenn Gulliksen.
Gulliksen had connections with Calvary Chapel in Costa Mesa, California. In 1974 he began a church in Hollywood that attracted many young people, including people connected with the entertainment industry.
Worship was particularly important.
Musicians and other artists became associated with the church, including figures such as Larry Norman, Chuck Girard, Bob Dylan, and Keith Green.
Gulliksen began planting additional churches and eventually gave them the name Vineyard, drawing on biblical imagery from Isaiah 27 and John 15.
By 1982, there were at least seven Vineyard churches operating as a loose network.
The movement might have remained a small California church-planting network.
Then John Wimber entered the story.
John Wimber: A Biography
4
John Wimber (1934–1997) was born in Kirksville, Missouri, and grew up to become a professional musician.
He eventually worked in the music industry and was associated with The Righteous Brothers as a musician and producer.
His life changed dramatically when he became a Christian in the 1960s.
Wimber was approximately 29 years old when he converted to Christianity. His early Christian formation was significantly influenced by a Quaker Bible study, and Quaker spirituality remained an important influence on him. In particular, Vineyard practices of waiting quietly before God and listening for the Spirit have Quaker roots.
Wimber initially became a highly successful evangelical pastor and evangelist.
By 1970 he was leading numerous Bible studies involving hundreds of people. He eventually became associated with the Charles E. Fuller Institute of Evangelism and Church Growth and taught at Fuller Theological Seminary, where his courses on signs, wonders, and church growth attracted extraordinary interest.
His theology was changing, however.
Wimber became convinced that the supernatural ministry described in the New Testament was not merely a feature of the apostolic age.
Jesus still heals. The Holy Spirit still gives spiritual gifts. Christians should still pray for the sick.
That conviction would become the foundation of the Vineyard.
Wimber and the Kingdom of God
One of Wimber’s most important theological influences was theologian George Eldon Ladd.
Ladd’s teaching on the Kingdom of God gave Wimber a theological framework for understanding how Christians could affirm both evangelical theology and contemporary supernatural ministry.
The basic idea was the “already and not yet” Kingdom.
God’s Kingdom has already arrived through Jesus Christ, but it has not yet reached its final consummation.
Therefore Christians can expect to experience something of the future Kingdom in the present.
Healing, prophecy, evangelism, deliverance, and other manifestations of the Spirit could be understood as anticipations of the Kingdom that is still to come.
This became one of the distinctive theological features of the Vineyard.
Wimber summarized his approach through the phrase “doing the stuff”—actually attempting to practice the ministry of Jesus rather than merely studying it.
Vineyard Anaheim
In 1977, Wimber founded a Calvary Chapel congregation in Yorba Linda, California.
The congregation grew rapidly.
A significant moment came in 1979, when Wimber invited Lonnie Frisbee, a charismatic evangelist associated with the Jesus Movement, to minister.
Frisbee prayed, “Come, Holy Spirit,” and the meeting became an extraordinary charismatic experience, with people reporting manifestations including falling, shaking, crying, and speaking in tongues. Vineyard Canada identifies this event as a pivotal moment in Wimber’s development and the movement’s history.
The experience created tension with Calvary Chapel’s leadership.
In 1982, Wimber’s congregation left Calvary Chapel and became Anaheim Vineyard Christian Fellowship.
This was the decisive moment in the formation of the modern Vineyard.
Kenn Gulliksen subsequently asked Wimber to assume leadership of the growing Vineyard network.
Thus the Vineyard effectively acquired its two defining leaders:
Gulliksen provided the original Vineyard network; Wimber provided the theological and organizational leadership that transformed it into a worldwide movement.
The Vineyard’s “Radical Middle”
Wimber did not want the Vineyard simply to become another Pentecostal denomination.
He also did not want it to abandon evangelical theology.
Instead, he attempted to hold the two traditions together.
The Vineyard wanted:
- The authority of Scripture
- Evangelical theology
- Evangelism
- Church planting
- Christ-centered discipleship
while also emphasizing:
- Healing
- Prophecy
- Spiritual gifts
- The present activity of the Holy Spirit
- Experiencing God’s presence
- Contemporary worship
Vineyard leaders have described this approach as seeking the “radical middle” between evangelicalism and Pentecostal/charismatic Christianity.
This explains why the Vineyard has often been difficult to categorize.
It is charismatic without being classically Pentecostal.
It is evangelical without being cessationist.
It is experiential without wanting experience to replace Scripture.
That tension would become increasingly important as the movement grew.
The Vineyard and Contemporary Worship Music
Perhaps the Vineyard’s most visible contribution to Christianity has been worship music.
The Vineyard helped transform how evangelicals thought about congregational worship.
The movement emphasized songs that were:
- Simple
- Contemporary
- Congregational
- Intimate
- Jesus-centered
- Experiential
Rather than primarily singing about God, Vineyard worship encouraged Christians to sing directly to God.
Vineyard USA describes intimate worship as one of the movement’s defining characteristics, while Vineyard Worship continues to gather, develop, record, and distribute songs produced within Vineyard churches.
This helped create a new worship vocabulary.
Instead of primarily singing formal hymns about Christian doctrine, congregations increasingly sang songs expressing:
“I love you, Lord.”
“Come, Holy Spirit.”
“Jesus, I want to know you.”
The emphasis was on personal relationship and intimacy with God.
Vineyard Music
The movement’s worship songs were recorded and distributed far beyond Vineyard churches.
This helped Vineyard worship become a major influence on the broader contemporary Christian music movement.
Songwriters and worship leaders associated with Vineyard worship included people such as:
- Brian Doerksen
- Brent Helming
- Kevin Prosch
- Marc Nelson
- Andy Park
- David Ruis
- Vicky Beeching
- Kathryn Scott
- Jeremy Riddle
The influence crossed denominational boundaries.
Vineyard songs became common in evangelical, charismatic, Pentecostal, Anglican, Baptist, and independent churches.
The Vineyard was therefore not merely creating a distinctive style of worship for its own churches.
It was helping create the worship culture that would eventually become normal across much of evangelical Christianity.
“Intimate Worship”
One of the most significant changes was the emotional vocabulary of worship.
Earlier evangelical worship often emphasized God’s greatness, holiness, sovereignty, and majesty.
Vineyard worship did not abandon those themes.
But it added an emphasis on intimacy.
God was not merely the sovereign creator.
He was Father.
Jesus was not merely Savior.
He was also friend and Lord.
The Holy Spirit was not merely a theological doctrine.
The Spirit was someone whose presence could be experienced.
This approach profoundly influenced later worship movements.
The Vineyard and “Power Evangelism”
Wimber also developed an influential approach to evangelism called power evangelism.
Traditional evangelical evangelism often emphasized preaching and apologetics.
Wimber believed those things remained essential but argued that evangelism could also involve demonstrations of God’s power.
A Christian might:
- Share the gospel.
- Listen for what God might be saying.
- Pray for someone.
- Pray for healing.
- Look for opportunities to demonstrate God’s love.
Wimber’s book ** Power Evangelism ** became one of the movement’s most influential publications. It eventually sold more than one million copies and was named by Christianity Today in 2006 as one of the fifty most significant Christian books of the previous fifty years.
The Vineyard and the Third Wave
The Vineyard became one of the leading expressions of what has been called the Third Wave of the Holy Spirit.
The term is associated particularly with theologian C. Peter Wagner, who taught alongside Wimber at Fuller Seminary.
The terminology described a movement that was distinct from both:
- Classical Pentecostalism
- The Charismatic Movement within established denominations
The Third Wave emphasized supernatural ministry while attempting to avoid some of the denominational structures and theological distinctives of Pentecostalism.
The Vineyard became its most prominent institutional expression.
Wimber’s teaching also influenced people outside the Vineyard, including pastors and theologians from a variety of denominations.
The Kansas City Prophets
The 1980s and early 1990s brought another significant controversy.
The Vineyard developed relationships with leaders associated with the Kansas City Prophets, including Paul Cain, Mike Bickle, and Bob Jones.
These leaders emphasized prophecy and contemporary prophetic ministry.
Wimber initially welcomed aspects of this movement.
However, concerns eventually emerged over prophetic practices and accountability.
Wimber responded by attempting to correct problems while maintaining what he regarded as legitimate prophetic ministry.
This episode reinforced the tension at the heart of the Vineyard:
How can a church remain open to supernatural experiences while maintaining theological and pastoral accountability?
That question would become even more important in Toronto.
The Toronto Blessing
On January 20, 1994, a major revival began at Toronto Airport Vineyard, a Vineyard church led by John and Carol Arnott.
The visiting speaker was Randy Clark, a Vineyard pastor from Missouri.
The meetings became associated with extraordinary manifestations of the Holy Spirit.
People reported:
- Falling to the floor
- Trembling
- Crying
- Laughter
- Extended worship
- Prophecy
- Experiences of spiritual renewal
- Reported physical and emotional healing
The phenomenon became known as the “Toronto Blessing.”
Within months, thousands of people were traveling to Toronto.
The church had to move to larger facilities, and services could last for hours. Contemporary reporting described crowds of thousands and international interest.
The Toronto Blessing quickly became an international phenomenon.
Why Was Toronto So Important?
Toronto represented both the strength and weakness of the Vineyard.
On one hand, the movement demonstrated the Vineyard’s ability to facilitate charismatic renewal without abandoning an evangelical identity.
People from many different denominations came to Toronto.
They returned to their churches reporting spiritual renewal and began incorporating some of the worship and ministry practices they had encountered.
On the other hand, some of the physical manifestations raised serious theological questions.
Critics questioned whether all of the manifestations were genuinely the work of the Holy Spirit.
Others criticized the emphasis placed on physical manifestations.
Still others worried about inadequate theological accountability.
The debate became increasingly intense.
Why Did the Vineyard Break with Toronto?
In December 1995, the Association of Vineyard Churches formally severed its relationship with Toronto Airport Vineyard.
John Wimber personally traveled to Toronto to communicate the decision.
The reasons included concerns about manifestations, ministry practices, pastoral oversight, and whether the church was operating within the Vineyard’s agreed standards of leadership and accountability. Contemporary reporting confirms that the decision was a major source of controversy within the movement.
The church subsequently became known as Toronto Airport Christian Fellowship and eventually Catch the Fire Toronto.
The separation was extremely significant.
It demonstrated that Wimber’s “radical middle” had boundaries.
The Vineyard was prepared to embrace charismatic experience—but not without limits.
The Long-Term Impact of Toronto
The Toronto Blessing did not disappear when the church left the Vineyard.
Its influence spread internationally.
Toronto became associated with a wider renewal movement and influenced other charismatic revivals, churches, worship movements, and ministries.
The experience also contributed to the development of networks outside the Vineyard.
Vineyard Canada acknowledges that the Toronto episode produced both blessing and controversy, and that the separation represented a major turning point in the movement.
In other words, Toronto changed both the Vineyard and the wider charismatic world.
John Wimber’s Final Years
The Toronto controversy occurred during the final years of Wimber’s life.
He continued leading the Vineyard while dealing with serious health problems.
Wimber died in November 1997.
He was only 63.
His death created a major leadership transition.
Wimber had been more than the movement’s administrative leader.
He had been its theological architect, most recognizable teacher, international ambassador, and spiritual father.
The question was whether the Vineyard could maintain its identity without him.
The Vineyard After Wimber
After Wimber’s death, leadership passed through several stages.
The movement continued expanding internationally.
The Vineyard developed churches throughout:
- North America
- Britain
- Europe
- Africa
- Australia
- New Zealand
- Asia
- Latin America
Vineyard Canada became an independent national movement in 1995, making it the first country outside the United States to receive independent status within the Vineyard family.
The movement continued to emphasize its distinctive combination of:
Word + Spirit + Kingdom + Mission.
The Anaheim Vineyard Crisis
Another major event occurred much more recently.
Vineyard Anaheim had remained the historic “mother church” of the movement.
It was the church where Wimber had pastored, where many Vineyard leaders had been trained, and where much of the movement’s theology and worship culture had developed.
After years of difficulty and declining attendance, the church experienced a period of renewal under Alan and Kathryn Scott, who became its leaders.
But in March 2022, Vineyard Anaheim announced that it was leaving Vineyard USA.
The departure was extremely controversial.
Vineyard USA described the decision as shocking and deeply painful, emphasizing the church’s historic significance to the entire movement.
The congregation subsequently became known as The Dwelling Place.
The episode was particularly significant because this was not simply another local Vineyard church leaving the movement.
It was the mother church itself.
Why Anaheim’s Departure Matters
The Anaheim controversy illustrates how much the Vineyard has changed since Wimber’s death.
The movement that began around one charismatic leader had become an international network of churches with different leaders, theological emphases, worship styles, and approaches to ministry.
Anaheim’s departure raised questions about:
- Leadership
- Institutional authority
- Property
- Local church autonomy
- The meaning of Vineyard identity
- The relationship between the movement’s history and its future
Whatever one’s interpretation of the controversy, it represents an important milestone in the history of the movement.
The historic church where Wimber led the Vineyard for fifteen years was no longer part of the organization he had helped create.
What Does the Vineyard Believe?
The Vineyard has generally occupied a position between traditional evangelicalism and Pentecostalism.
Its theology emphasizes:
Biblical Christianity
The movement remains committed to the historic Christian faith and the authority of Scripture.
The Kingdom of God
The Kingdom is already present through Jesus but awaits its final consummation.
The Holy Spirit
The gifts and ministry of the Spirit continue today.
Healing
Christians are encouraged to pray for physical and emotional healing.
Evangelism
The church exists to reach people who do not yet follow Jesus.
Worship
Worship should be intimate, contemporary, and centered on Jesus.
Compassion and Justice
Vineyard churches have generally emphasized practical ministry to people in need.
The result is a distinctive synthesis:
Evangelical theology + charismatic spirituality + contemporary worship + Kingdom theology + evangelistic mission.
The Vineyard’s Greatest Contribution
It is difficult to overstate the Vineyard’s influence on contemporary Christianity.
Consider how common it is today for an evangelical church to have:
- Contemporary worship bands
- Extended worship
- Songs sung directly to Jesus
- Prayer for healing
- Prophetic prayer
- Informal worship settings
- Small groups
- Church planting
- Expectation of the Holy Spirit’s presence
None of these originated with the Vineyard.
But the Vineyard helped bring many of these practices together in a form that could be adopted by churches that would never have identified themselves as Pentecostal.
Its greatest achievement may therefore have been bridging traditions.
The Vineyard and Modern Worship
The influence of Vineyard worship is particularly obvious.
The movement helped popularize a style of worship characterized by:
simplicity, intimacy, repetition, emotional honesty, and direct address to God.
That style eventually became influential far beyond the Vineyard.
Many churches today would find the worship environment of the 1980s Vineyard completely ordinary.
That is an indication of just how successful its influence has been.
The Vineyard did not invent contemporary Christian worship.
But it helped transform contemporary worship into a theology of intimacy with God.
A Movement Still Wrestling With Its Identity
The history of the Vineyard is therefore partly a story about balance.
Wimber wanted to preserve two things that frequently seemed incompatible:
the evangelical commitment to Scripture
and
the charismatic expectation of the Holy Spirit’s activity.
He wanted Christians to preach the gospel and pray for the sick.
He wanted theological seriousness and spiritual experience.
He wanted worship that was emotionally intimate without becoming merely emotional.
He wanted the supernatural without abandoning accountability.
That balance worked remarkably well for several decades.
But the controversies surrounding the Kansas City Prophets, Toronto Blessing, and eventually Anaheim demonstrate how difficult that balance can be.
Conclusion
The Vineyard began in the spiritual ferment of the Jesus Movement of the 1970s.
Kenn Gulliksen established the original Vineyard network, but John Wimber transformed it into an international movement.
Wimber’s background was unusual. A former professional musician and recent Christian convert, he became an evangelical pastor who gradually became convinced that the supernatural ministry described in the New Testament remained available to the church.
His theology was profoundly shaped by the Kingdom of God, particularly through the influence of George Eldon Ladd.
The result was a movement that attempted to occupy the “radical middle” between evangelical and charismatic Christianity.
The Vineyard’s influence on worship music may ultimately be its most enduring legacy. Its emphasis on intimate, contemporary worship helped reshape the musical vocabulary of evangelical Christianity, while Vineyard songs spread far beyond Vineyard churches.
But the movement’s history also demonstrates the difficulty of maintaining the balance Wimber envisioned.
The Toronto Blessing brought unprecedented international attention while simultaneously producing controversy and ultimately a painful separation from the Vineyard.
And in 2022, the departure of Vineyard Anaheim, the movement’s historic mother church, provided another dramatic reminder that the Vineyard is no longer simply John Wimber’s movement.
Nevertheless, the basic Vineyard vision continues to have considerable influence:
Know the Bible.
Love Jesus.
Welcome the Holy Spirit.
Pray for the sick.
Worship intimately.
Share the gospel.
Live the Kingdom of God now while awaiting its fullness.
That combination explains why a small network of California churches emerging from the Jesus Movement became one of the most influential renewal movements in modern evangelical Christianity.
